For friends and family of those with mood disorders, part 1--Don't tell me to snap out of it

Mental illness is often misunderstood and stigmatized, which is one reason I'm very open about having bipolar disorder (also called manic depression)--As long as people are ashamed of mental illness, the stigma will continue. Our illness does not define us, but it is a part of our daily lives, and those close to us (or who want to be close to us) need to understand our illness to deal with us, just as we need to understand and learn how to deal with them and the things that affect their lives.

Being a friend or family member of someone with bipolar disorder can be a challenge, especially for those who do not understand it--And many people, even the aforementioned family and friends, don't understand, "Well, everybody gets depressed," some say, and, "just snap out of it." These people do not fully understand what it is to have a physical disorder that affects their brain chemistry.

Let me give you an exercise to help you understand how useless it is to tell us to snap out of it.

First, find a friend who is willing to be very mean to you, and have them read this essay and promise to help you with the exercise.

Now go buy a bottle of tequila, or vodka, or whatever alcoholic beverage you prefer. Go ahead. I'll wait. If you don't normally drink, do it just this once just for the purpose of the exercise--Believe it or not, I am serious about this. If you truly care and want to understand what your bipolar friend or loved one is going through, but have never been drunk, or under so much pain medication that you couldn't function, or something similar to one of those that chemically altered your state of mind to the point at which you were essentially non-functional, you need to do this if you are serious about understanding what a person with a mood disorder goes through.

Or you can just admit that you don't really want to understand.

Now, assuming you've decided that you really want to understand, drink. Drink until you can't walk straight. Drink until you start slurring your words, your vision gets blurry, and you have trouble seeing straight. Drink until you feel sick and want nothing more than to lay down, but when you do lay the room seems to spin around you, and it just makes things worse.

Now the friend comes in. He or she will now tell you something to the effect of, "Come on; just snap yourself out of it. Right now. Don't wait for the chemical in your body to metabolize and go away. Just. Stop. Being. Drunk."

Okay, that isn't working, but your friend needs to keep telling you anyway, throughout this entire exercise.

In the next phase of this exercise, your friend will decide that he or she knows how to force you to sober up.

Now it is time for your friend to get you up off the floor--forcibly, if necessary, and pour coffee down your throat. If that makes you throw up, drink more alcohol. It is essential to this experience that you have large amounts of alcohol in your system for an extended period of time. In fact, drink some more booze whether you just threw up or not, just to be sure. Why is he or she pouring coffee down your throat? Well, it's supposed to sober you up, isn't it? Just like when you tell someone suffering from a mood disorder, "Just go(fill in the blank) and you'll feel better," it is supposed to make their mood disorder stop affecting them.

Now your friend is going to make you run around the building until you are gasping for breath and about about to fall down from exhaustion.

Now drink some more.

After you've had some more to drink, your friend must force you into a cold shower. With your clothes on. After you are thoroughly cold and soaked, drink some more. And keep drinking.

Sober yet? What's that, you say? Too much booze in your system for you to possibly sober up? The only way to sober up is to wait until the alcohol is out of your system?

Nope. You obviously just don't want to sober up. Just like people with chemical mood disorders don't want to stop being depressed, or manic, or whatever. By the way, at this point, you should be a cold, wet, tired, wide-awake, and very pissed off drunk.

Okay, end of exercise. Go sleep it off, and get through your hangover the next day as best you can.

Now imagine what life would be like if the alcohol were coming from inside your own body, and that you could never know when it was going to start or how much it would produce. Neither do you know how long it will last each time. It could be hours, days, weeks, months, or even years.

Congratulations. You now have some idea of what it is like to have bipolar disorder--To have chemicals in your body that can sometimes nearly incapacitate you, and to know that you can do very little about it except wait until they go away.

If, after this exercise, you ever again tell someone with a chemical mood disorder to, "just snap out it," I hope he or she beats the bejeezus out of you. You'll deserve it.

Comments

JTigerclaw's picture

Thanks

Thank you for this article. I don't have manic depression, but my close friend does, and this information is helpful for getting me to better understand what it's like. I've never told her to just 'snap out of it', but I have wondered why it seems impossible to cheer her up when she gets that way. Now I know. Thanks alot, and I'm looking forward to more entries on this topic in the future.

D. Robert Hamm's picture

Thanks, Jon, and I'm glad

Thanks, Jon, and I'm glad you got something out of it. I wrote it in hopes, of course, that it might help people understand why we're not always grateful for attempts to force us to cheer up. It's like, "Yeah, I'd LOVE to cheer up, but it isn't that simple." Next, I'm planning to write about what it's like to have a mood disorder from the perspective of the ill person, and follow that up with treatments and coping strategies for both the person with the mood disorder and his or her loved ones.

Anonymous's picture

Amen

Been there. Done that. Sent the postcard to my aunt. Bought the t-shirt. Sold the theme park.

Care to read what my favorite of the "just snap out of it" genre is?

"It's all in your head."

When confronted with logic like that, who needs therapists? Right?

My family used that one a lot. Particularly during the early-20's breakdown, I would hear that one on a semi-daily basis. (Don't lets start on the mid-20's breakdown. Tends to get me depressed.) I tended to just look at them like they were the biggest idiots on the planet. And eventually they would get the hint.

Eventually.

Anonymous's picture

Salt on the wound

My mother's favorite one was, 'Everyone's pulling for you, except you.' Good luck. Take things one day at a time, and if that doesn't work, hour by hour.

Anubis's picture

I can defiantly understand

I can defiantly understand that your saying, As well as doing blood bound, I am a full time carer for a woman and her family, she has Bipolar as well as borderline personality disorder, an horrible mix at times.